Reality Contestants Vie for Spotlight, Face Judges’ Unflinching Scrutiny

HONG KONG — The latest episode of ViuTV’s popular talent competition, King Maker VI, delivered a mix of chaotic enthusiasm and disciplined performance, culminating in a surprising elimination and sharp critiques on ensemble chemistry. The broadcast, featuring intense self-selected performances and vocal battles, highlighted the unpredictable journey of aspiring idols under high-stakes pressure.

The show immediately focused on Group A2’s self-selected performance, titled “The Vibe Has Arrived! 2025.” Member Ian Hannz (No. 43), sought a comedic, high-energy approach, stating he aimed for “an eccentric vitality” and a willingness to “go completely wild.” This led to a visually exuberant act featuring rolling, writhing on the floor, and even the deliberate removal of clothing, including a belt.

The performance, however, divided professional opinion. During the rehearsal check, Jeremy from MIRROR expressed strong reservations, noting significant synchronization issues. “The moment that should have been your tightest was your weakest,” Jeremy criticized, questioning the artistic necessity of removing a belt during the routine, ultimately stating the performance was “a mess” that failed to earn any extra credit.

Conversely, following the main performance, judge Kenny Kwan praised the group’s commitment. “They caught the vibe and entered the state the moment they stepped on stage,” he remarked, celebrating the apparent “boy group bonding” among the four members. Singer Stephanie Cheng found the group endearing, while Peter Chan, known for his high standards, acknowledged the performance brought joy but lacked lasting impact.

The tension escalated during the subsequent Sing Battle between Group A2 and Group B3. Group B3, whose members Larry, Biu, and Yip had previously displayed particularly weak vocal skills during initial auditions, entered the battle under intense scrutiny. Despite vocal failures in earlier rounds, mentor Gin Lee expressed considerable confidence in the B3 lineup, though the celebrity judges admitted anxiety upon seeing their song choices, “Black Glass” and “The Death of Love Brain.”

The Battle featured stunning vocal surprises. Drummer Muddy from Rubberband lauded the performances of TUZERO and Teller, specifically pointing out Biu’s unexpectedly strong singing, which elicited a “Wow.” Stephanie Cheng also noted Biu’s improvement, saying his performance was “not awkward,” suggesting his overall appeal allowed judges to overlook minor flaws.

Ultimate praise, however, went to Ian Hannz of Group A2, whose vocal talent impressed both Kenny Kwan and Kitty Yuen. Kwan highlighted A2’s overall presence, noting that despite having only four members, their “penetrating power” was aurally greater than B3’s. Nevertheless, Group B3 secured a decisive victory with a five-light sweep.

The elimination saw Kenrick (A2) and Yinhei (A2) depart the competition. Kenrick reflected on his personal growth, crediting his mentor, stating he transitioned from an introverted individual who “didn’t dare to smile” to someone gradually opening up. Yinhei accepted the decision philosophically, believing the outcome was “the best arrangement.”

The episode concluded by introducing the next group for elimination: Group B2. Known for their active participation, Gin Lee commended the group, which includes Winson (No. 20) and Michael (No. 35), for rapidly preparing their material just three days after the previous round.

Despite their swift preparation, the B2 team faced internal discord and external criticism. Key member Michael frequently missed rehearsals due to external work commitments, even skipping the key rehearsal check. Furthermore, friction within the group, particularly involving Su Jai (No. 68), was evident; Su Jai had controversially volunteered for elimination during a selection process before successfully reconciling with teammates.

Their self-selected performance, “Close To Love,” failed to resonate with the panel. Kitty Yuen felt Su Jai lacked tension and failed to fully utilize his unique qualities. Kenny Kwan suggested Su Jai was too “chill” and questioned why the contestant wasn’t showcasing his full potential in the competition. Peter Chan delivered the harshest critique, determining the performance was caught between “awkwardness and enjoyment.” Chan observed a lack of organic chemistry, stating that each member appeared to be “treading carefully,” which hindered the group’s cohesiveness. Group B2 now faces an uphill battle in the subsequent Sing Battle to avoid elimination.