The protracted internal tensions within the acclaimed Hong Kong band Mr. escalated recently after former lead vocalist Alan Po voiced public accusations of betrayal and creative friction against his ex-bandmates. This public spat follows the band’s 2023 reunion, where they performed and released new material but conspicuously without Po, reducing the lineup from five to four members following their initial disbandment in 2016. The drama centers on the sensitive issues of song ownership and performance credits, echoing longstanding creative differences among the rock group.
The controversy was amplified when Po took to social media, launching thinly veiled criticism at his former collaborators, alleging issues that arose during the songwriting and performance processes, confessing to feelings of being “betrayed.” This prompted a suspected retort from guitarist Ronny Lai, who allegedly used lyrics from the band’s track “STORM” – specifically, the line, “You are sick, medicine won’t cure it” – in what appeared to be a public challenge.
Responding to the heated exchange at a wrap-up dinner for the television drama Behind the Scenery on Monday, Ronny Lai addressed the situation directly. Lai offered a public apology, stating, “We hope he calms down. If anything made him unhappy, we sincerely apologize.” He sought to clarify a perceived misattribution: “When promoting the Guangzhou show, I introduced the song ‘Forest’ as being performed by Mr., which is why I said ‘we sang it.’ Perhaps he became sensitive.” Lai also stressed the practical reality of their music: “When the song was recorded, it was indeed his voice. We have no dispute about that.”
Lai confirmed that communication between himself and Po has ceased for a considerable time, suggesting that any future contact would require the right circumstances. “He is a bit agitated right now. Everyone should focus on their own work first,” the guitarist remarked. When questioned about the potential for reconciliation and a full reunion, Lai maintained a cautious stance.
Future Collaboration Uncertain
Reflecting on the possibility of Mr. performing as a five-piece once more, Lai expressed deep uncertainty. He acknowledged the collective desire of the fanbase for the original lineup but emphasized the need for genuine resolution over financial incentives.
“Nothing is permanently impossible in this world, but I don’t know,” Lai said. “I am just a small guitarist, only one-fifth of the group. It depends on everyone. I believe the fans definitely want us to be complete, but it should be under positive circumstances, not just for the sake of making money.”
Beyond the band conflict, Lai shared details about his acting role in Behind the Scenery, where he portrays a Malaysian businessman, departing from his frequent typecasting as an antagonist. He expressed delight at the opportunity to work alongside veteran actress Athena Chu and spoke of his admiration for her husband, the musician Paul Wong, a long-time personal idol.
The public feud highlights the often-turbulent nature of creative partnerships, underscoring the legal and emotional complexities that arise when musical entities dissolve and later attempt to reform. For supporters of Mr., the core question remains whether the former frontman can reconcile his grievances with the remaining members to satisfy the audience’s wish for the full band’s return. The current focus for all involved appears to be individual professional pursuits until a more appropriate time for dialogue emerges.
